2114 Bonnycastle Ave,Louisville, KY 40205
Louisville, KY 40205
Description
Located in the heart of Louisville's highly desirable Highlands neighborhood, this exceptional four-plex is a rare opportunity on one of the city's most iconic streets within one of its strongest rental markets. This stately three-story brick property features four spacious units ranging from one to three bedrooms, each offering unique character with features such as sunrooms, butler's pantries, and mudrooms. Additional amenities include a full basement with laundry, a large fenced backyard, and three rear garages. The sellers recently inherited the property and have limited historical knowledge beyond its long-standing history as a stable, income-producing rental with very low vacancy. Recognizing the property would benefit from updates, they have significantly reduced the price to reflect known repairs. Contractor estimates are attached to the listing, and the sellers are willing to provide a repair credit or adjust the purchase price accordingly. The oversized first-floor unit, offering more than 2,000 square feet with three bedrooms and two bathrooms, is currently vacant and may remain available for an owner-occupant or immediate renovations before leasing. With its generous unit sizes, classic architecture, and prime location, the property offers excellent value-add potential through renovations and increased rental income. It also presents a unique opportunity for conversion back to a grand single-family residence, subject to applicable approvals. Whether you're an investor or owner-occupant, this is a rare Highlands property offering outstanding flexibility, upside potential, and long-term value.
Details
| MLS # | 1714238 |
|---|---|
| Listing Type | For Sale |
| Sub-Type | Resale |
| Status | Active |
| Year | 1925 |
| Days On Site | 132 |
| Listing Provided By | Homepage Realty | Amanda Helfrich |
Features
| Bed(s) | 8 |
|---|---|
| Bath(s) | 5 |
| SQ Feet | 5,200 |
| Garage | 3 |
| Basement | Y |
| Units | 4 |
| Acreage | 0.21 |
Area Information
| State | KY |
|---|---|
| County | Jefferson |
| City | Louisville |
| Zip Code | 40205 |
| Area | 02 Butchertwn | Hghlnds | Germantwn |
| Listing VS Median (in 40205) | |
Price: $749,000 low | high Med: $355,000 sqft: 5,200 low | high Med: 2,138 $ / sqft: $144 low | high Med: $166 On site: 132 low | high Med: 100 | |
Market Activity 40205
Request a showing
Request a showing
Contact
Learn More About This Property
| State | KY |
|---|---|
| County | Jefferson |
| City | Louisville |
| Zip Code | 40205 |
| Area | 02 Butchertwn | Hghlnds | Germantwn |
| Listing VS Median (in 40205) | |
Price: $749,000 low | high Med: $355,000 sqft: 5,200 low | high Med: 2,138 $ / sqft: $144 low | high Med: $166 On site: 132 low | high Med: 100 | |
 |  |  |
© 2026 Coldwell Banker McMahan. All Rights Reserved. Coldwell Banker® and the Coldwell Banker Logo are registered service marks owned by Coldwell Banker Real Estate LLC. Coldwell Banker McMahan fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and Equal Opportunity Act. Each franchise is independently owned and operated. Any services or products provided by independently owned and operated franchises are not provided by, affiliated with or related to Coldwell Banker Real Estate LLC nor any of its affiliated companies.
